aillarionov: (Default)
[personal profile] aillarionov
The Kiel Institute for the World Economy has published a second report on the amount of assistance to Ukraine in its efforts to repel Russian aggression. This time, the time coverage of the analysis was tripled – from January 24, 2022 (the date when some of NATO troops was put on alert) until April 23, 2022. The Institute's database takes into account three main types of assistance – financial, humanitarian, military. Below are the data mainly on the military component of the aid. The amount of US military assistance has been corrected in accordance with official Pentagon statements.

From January 24 to April 23, Ukraine's 26 allies provided it with military assistance worth $10.2 billion. On average for these 26 countries, military aid provided to Ukraine over the three months amounted to 0.025% of their combined GDP, 0.89% of their annual military spending, $11.8 per capita.

The military aid provided to Ukraine as of April 23 is 3.6 times more than the estimated total military aid during the first month of the war, from February 24 to March 27. While military assistance from Ukraine's largest allies has grown at a very high rate (from Poland – almost 27 times, Germany – 11 times, Great Britain – 3.7 times), military assistance from the United States increased much more slowly – by only 2.7 times.



In terms of the absolute size of military aid, the United States is still in the lead – 3.9 billion dollars for last three months. However, due to a faster increase in military assistance from other countries, the share of the United States in total military assistance to Ukraine decreased from 52.3% on March 27 to 38.9% on April 23.

In terms of the relative size of military aid, the United States not only lags far behind Ukraine’s other allies, but this gap even widens, being now:
- in terms of military aid per capita – it is 11th out of 26 countries (as of March 27 – it was 8th out of 23 countries);
- in terms of military aid as a share of GDP – it is 14th (as of March 27 – it was 11th);
- in terms of military aid as a share of military spending – it is 17th (as of March 27 – it was 18th).

In terms of the relative size of military aid, Estonia remains the undisputed leader among Ukraine's allies. It sent 220 million euros (240 million dollars) of military aid to the victim of aggression, that is, almost a third of its annual military budget, which is 0.8% of Estonia's GDP or 180 dollars per capita.



The same amount – 220 million euros – was provided to Ukraine by Latvia, which is 29% of its annual military spending, 0.71% of GDP and 127 dollars per capita.

Following Estonia and Latvia in terms of military aid to Ukraine as a share of their own military spending are Poland – almost a quarter (23.6%) – and Slovakia – more than a fifth (21.8%).

These four leading countries, together with Canada and Germany, over three months sent military aid to Ukraine in the amount of $4.5 billion, which is 13% more than the military aid provided by the USA. The total military assistance to Ukraine from these six countries (Estonia, Latvia, Poland, Slovakia, Canada, Germany) turned out to be more than from the US, not only absolutely, but also relatively: per capita – one and a half times, in terms of share in GDP – 2.4 times, in terms of the share in its own military spending – 5.9 times.



In terms of the relative size of military assistance to Ukraine, Estonia is followed by:
- in terms of military aid per capita – Latvia, Poland, Slovakia, Canada, Lithuania, Germany;
- in terms of military aid as a percentage of GDP – Latvia, Poland, Slovakia, Lithuania, Canada, Germany;
- in terms of military aid as a share in the military spending of the donor country – Latvia, Poland, Slovakia, Lithuania, Canada, Ireland.



In relative terms military aid to Ukraine, the United States still lags far behind Estonia:
- in terms of military aid per capita – the US ($11.9) is 15 times behind Estonia ($180);
- in terms of military aid as a percentage of GDP – the US (0.019%) is 41 times behind Estonia (0.78%);
- in terms of the military aid as a share of the military spending of the donor country, the United States (0.50%) is 63 times behind Estonia (31.35%).

Date: 2022-05-04 05:54 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] merinainen.livejournal.com
Так а что толку? Города бомбят как бомбили.

Date: 2022-05-04 06:15 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ludvig gerhard (from livejournal.com)
Придётся всё же совершить пересчёт. Сложились новые обстоятельства. Как теперь рассматривать помощь США на весьма выгодных условиях для Украины по Лендлизу? Во-первых, Украине платить не нужно, так как деньги пойдут из арестованного золотовалютного фонда РФ в США и арестованного разноформатного добра русских олигархов и коррупционеров в США. Во-вторых, теперь украинское руководство решает, сколько и какого вооружения им необходимо, и не ждёт подачки. В-третьих, ВПК США теперь заинтересован в хорошем темпе воспроизводства вооружений на огромный заказ. В-четвёртых, Путин или Патрушев теперь не смогут упрекнуть или пригрозить США ядерным ответом на помощь Украине тяжёлым наступательным вооружением. В-пятых, Украина получит не старое залежалое, но новое и совершенное оружие. В-шестых, Лендлиз - не помощь, а долгоиграющий контракт не с правительством США, а с предприятиями ВПК, насколько долго хватит арестованных счетов. Вероятно, Белый дом к этому и подталкивал, ограничивая свою помощь.
Edited Date: 2022-05-04 06:23 am (UTC)

Хроники Мариуполя

Date: 2022-05-04 09:15 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] valeryich2000.livejournal.com
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Z4I1xYbQxU
_

_
Edited Date: 2022-05-04 09:16 am (UTC)

Date: 2022-05-04 12:04 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] mvo.livejournal.com
Андрей Николаевич, а есть ли где-либо сравнения помощи Украине с переведенными деньгами в Россию с начала войны?

Скажем возьмем Германию.
Сколько помощи отправлено Украине vs сколько денег заплачено России за газ, нефть, уголь и проч с 24 февраля 2022? Чтобы можно было непосредственно суммы сравнивать: военное время, Украине vs России

Date: 2022-05-04 03:11 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] dlagno.livejournal.com
я посмотрел исходную таблицу с их данными, и там полностью отсутствует Турция.

Это упущение в трекере или действительно не было помощи от Турции, которую можно было бы выразить в денежном выражении?

Profile

aillarionov: (Default)
Illarionov

April 2023

S M T W T F S
       1
2 34 5 67 8
9 10 11 12131415
1617 18 19 2021 22
23 2425 2627 2829
30      

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated May. 25th, 2025 10:41 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios